Aside from pari passu or a priority scheme, historical insolvency laws used many methods for distributing losses. The Talmud (ca 200AD) envisaged that each remaining penny would be dealt out to each creditor in turn, until a creditor received all he was owed, or the money ran out. This meant the small creditors were more likely to be paid in full than large and powerful creditors.[37]
The priority system is reinforced by a line of case law, whose principle is to ensure that creditors cannot contract out of the statutory regime:
The general principle, according to the Mellish LJ in Re Jeavons, ex parte Mackay[38] is that "a person cannot make it a part of his contract that, in the event of bankruptcy, he is then to get some additional advantage which prevents the property being distributed under the bankruptcy laws." So in that case, Jeavons made a contract to give Brown & Co an armour plates patent, and in return Jeavons would get royalties. Jeavons also got a loan from Brown & Co. They agreed half the royalties would pay off the loan, but if Jeavons went insolvent, Brown & Co would not have to pay any royalties. The Court of Appeal held half the royalties would still need to be paid, because this was a special right for Brown & Co that only arose upon insolvency.
In a case where a creditor is owed money by an insolvent company, but also the creditor itself owes a sum to the company, Forster v Wilson[39] held that the creditor may set-off the debt, and only needs to pay the difference. The creditor does not have to pay all its debts to the company, and then wait with other unsecured creditors for an unlikely repayment.
However, this depends on the sums for set-off actually being in the creditors' possession. In British Eagle International Air Lines Ltd v Compaigne Nationale Air France,[40] a group of airlines, through the International Air Transport Association had a netting system to deal with all the expenses they incurred to one another efficiently. All paid into a common fund, and then at the end of each month, the sums were settled at once. British Eagle went insolvent and was a debtor overall to the scheme, but Air France owed it money. Air France claimed it should not have to pay British Eagle, was bound to pay into the netting scheme, and have the sums cleared there. The House of Lords said this would have the effect of evading the insolvency regime. It did not matter that the dominant purpose of the IATA scheme was for good business reasons. It was nevertheless void.
Belmont Park Investments Pty Ltd v BNY Corporate Trustee Services Ltd and Lehman Brothers Special Financing Inc observed that the general principle consists of two subrules — the anti-deprivation rule (formerly known as "fraud upon the bankruptcy law") and the pari passu rule, which are addressed to different mischiefs — and held that, in borderline cases, a commercially sensible transaction entered into in good faith should not be held to infringe the first rule.
All these anti-avoidance rules are, however, subject to the very large exception that creditors remain able to jump up the priority queue, through the creation of a security interest.
See also: Netting and Set-off (law)
Secured lending
Main articles: UK banking law, Banking law, and Security interest
The Bank of England (est 1694) is the lender to all other banks, at an interest rate set by the Monetary Policy Committee under the Bank of England Act 1998. When lending on money to businesses at a higher interest rate, banks will contract for fixed and floating charges to decrease their risk and stabilise profits.
Home
→ Main articles: UK banking law, Banking law, and Security interest
Langganan:
Posting Komentar (Atom)
BESTSELLER PRODUCTS
-
The Insolvency Act 1986 priority list Fixed charge holders Insolvency practitioner fees and expenses, s 176ZA Preferential credi...
-
Aside from pari passu or a priority scheme, historical insolvency laws used many methods for distributing losses. The Talmud (ca 200AD) envi...
-
Bosch HBL3550UC Double Electric Oven - Double - 9200W - Stainless Steel Package Contents: 300 HBL3550UC Double Electric Oven 3 x Oven Rac...
-
See also: Netting and Set-off (law) Secured lending Main articles: UK banking law, Banking law, and Security interest The Bank of England (e...
-
Whirlpool RBS245PRS Electric Single Wall Oven - Stainless Steel This single built-in oven features a 3.1 cu. ft. self-cleaning upper oven wi...
-
Infinity Instruments SV-3182 Datekeeper Wall Clock in Silver Infinity Instruments 14113SV-3182 Features: -Wall clock. -Metallic silver resi...
-
U.S. ARMY Digital Camo Chrome Double Ring Neon Clock Every game room, garage or man cave could use the addition of an officially licensed ne...
-
While both need to be registered, the distinction between a fixed and a floating charge matters greatly because floating charges are subordi...
-
In commercial practice the term "debenture" typically refers to the document that evidences a secured debt, although in law the de...
-
Frigidaire FGB24S5AS White 24" Single Gas Wall Oven with Ready-Select Controls Single Gas Wall Oven with Ready-Select Controls and ADA...
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar